Tuesday, May 20, 2008

The nature of Man's freewill

Still thinking on freewill from last week's post.
When considering freedom and freewill, there is the danger of too many laws hindering it, and the danger of too few stopping it all together. To many laws is a tyranny. Too few anarchy. Neither is freedom of choice. Therefore rules and laws cannot be the nemesis of our freewill, they are that which defines it. Humans are too limited, too finite, too uncreative to have freedom without them. We simply don't have enough creativity to "think" of something on our own. Our very limitations define our choices.

Without limits, the spectrum is too broad; choices become inconsequential.


If you ask a child what they want to be when they grow up, they may answer, "Spiderman!" or "A horsey!" Hardly viable options. Questions without qualifications become non-sense questions. What does blue taste like? Questions, I imagine, that even God can't answer because they defy the laws He has set into the permanence of the universe (or this one anyway.)
So even the question, "What do you want to do?" must have definition. When? When I retire? Tonight? What are my options? Have a game of pool with the guys, or become a doctor?

For our will to be constructive, our choices to have consequence, we must therefore have options put before us. As we saw before, no rules doesn't mean freedom, it means chaos. Nothingness. Soccer without the rules is just a ball to kick (or throw).

Nature, being finite herself also has rules she "follows." Some are easy for us to understand, some difficult, others perhaps impossible. Some don't even seem to meld together as far as we can see. Einstein despised the fact that he couldn't reconcile Newtonian (Classical) physics and quantum physics. Maybe someone will. Then we shall be even more satisfied, nature without rules is a less than a vacuum. Two plus two is four today and 738.243528 tomorrow. Atoms wouldn't form, much less apples. They certainly wouldn't fall from trees onto our heads.
The older philosophers and scientists had a great reverence for God. They knew that without His wisdom and order, they couldn't reason through the universe, nor would there be a universe to study. Atheism turns out to be too simple, as Lewis says.

So even when we invent something, it turns out to be more of a discovery of something already thought of by God. Don't worry, I'm not propounding neo-platonism.
"Necessity is the mother of all invention," is true to fact because the need defines what is needed. As an artist in college, I used to complain a lot about people who came up and said, "draw me something." What? You want a tree, a portrait, a chicken salad sandwich? A little direction is all that is needed. "Use your imagination," they would say. "It's somehow too broad and yet too narrow."
Artists were revered in our ancient past (oh, the days gone of long ago...) because people knew that insight and imagination were rare. The ability to express thoughts, to draw them out of the ether, divine.

Which brings me back to God. Whereas we are finite and nearsighted, in need of laws, limitations and the rules in order to make the simplest of decisions, God is infinite and infinitely creative. He can do anything 'that comes to mind.' But as He is the source of all ideas, no "new idea" could present itself to the Creator. He IS imagination. Being infinite and transtemporal, His ideas don't leak out over a good glass of wine, they always have been, just as He has been. They all come out at the fount of eternity itself. His thoughts Are, as He Is. They are Him, His thoughts His personality just as ours are.(1) His thoughts are 'what He has to say about Himself,' His Word: Christ. Ergo, the theology of John, "In the beginning was the Word, the Word was with God and the Word was God," and "all things are made by and for Christ" holds sound.

Lets try to break this down: God is infinite. Infinite Being means infinite Creativity. God's "Freewill" is His Word, Christ.
Man is finite and mortal, one must be given choices for one to choose, to have a freewill.
Christ becomes man, drawing Man into God, setting us free. God's laws are not so much rules to tell us how to live well, more of simple statements of reality. God saying, 'This is what I am like.' In our submission He breaks all the limitations we have set upon ourselves in sin. A man or woman in Christ can now do 'infinite things.' "You will do all this and more, in my name," and "I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me."
So, apparently, being in Christ is enlightening in the truest sense. The only way to break free is by submitting.
To die to self and be resurrected. Mind, body and spirit.

(1) We literally are created in His image.

6 comments:

Robin said...

An addition on the Trinity:

Christ is the Word, the Word is God's will - Again, as Lewis says, God is so full of being that He gives it away, His Word has a life of its own, yet is still Him. To some small extent explaining the first two persons of the Trinity. The third person, the Spirit is the love they share, the very action of their being. That Love, that Spirit has His own personality as well, so full of life and vitality is He, making the Trinity.
God the Source, God the Will and God the Action: The Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost.

Robin said...

i think i may not have been specific enough as to rules. I tried putting in the nature thing, but i guess it wasn't enough.
okay, so you are playing soccer. nope, just kicking a ball. but to do that, you still are relying on laws of gravity, momentum, perpetual motion, etc. without SOME rules, you can't do anything.
Your choices to eat an apple, kill your neighbor or go to work are still dependent upon apples being available, your neighbor not being a vary large blackbelt with a shotgun or you actually having a job to go to in the first place. Any choices you make are choices from a selection - no matter how broad that selection may be - which are defined by rules. So being that we HAVE to submit ourselves to Nature, does submitting yourself to God take away any "freewill?" No, in fact, i think after submitting to God, your choices are more real, made more valid, more consequential and for once, you are set free from the confining rules that (too many or too few, remember?) that we have put on us. Eg. Worldly materialistic mumbo-jumbo and cultural taboos.
Most of the "freewill choices" that people make are simply culturally imposed, situational or environmental. You like the clothes you like because they are on people you look up to, who are on TV because they have a nice chest and smile and attract the opposite sex, but who know nothing of YOU. I have the job I have because my father-in-law knew so and so and i was desperate. The list goes on and on. My choices are really not so much mine, my freewill not so free. Letting go of those constraints, and oddly, taking on others (God's) frees us from the monotony of self. In letting myself go, I find myself in Him. I submitting my will, it is freed.

Robin said...

I think I get what you're saying - that we are constrained by our natures and that doesn't actually take away our free will - but i think you need to be careful you don't confuse influence with control. I am influenced by the people on tv, you were influenced by AIko's dad, and those things made a certain choice more likely, but you still decided to make the choice. You could have told Aiko's dad no, and starved to death. Nothing was preventing you, except you. We take on God's constraints voluntarily, choosing to live His way because we believe that He knows better than we. His decisions are better informed than ours, and our choice to submit to Him is a rational choice that we decide to make. We become freed, but we choose to limit our free choices to those that line up with His. That sets us free (from sin and death etc), but it is our choice to do so.
(By DaveE)

Robin said...

i agree with you completely - what you have said is TRUE.
in your post, you had mentioned determinism and libertarian, right? i am not sure that BOTH are not the case. If you don't make conscious effort, then determinism may actually be true for you, in other words, you may not have as many choices as you think. most people just go along for the ride, and don't think so much as they think they do... i think. confused? me too.
But in exercising the will that God gave us, esp in choosing Him, we become free. what i am trying to say basically is this: God made nature and it MUST follow the rules set to it. you don't see physics defying itself. It does not have freewill. Whereas if we just go with the flow, whatever comes our way, as many people do (even in fashion), then we are just a part of nature, as a rock is in the stream. being worn down just the same. If we wake up, exercise that will God gave us, we are free, and the most freeing is to submit to God fully. The more fully you submit, the more free you become.

Anonymous said...

::sighs::

If only I could be more like God in the area of creativity. How clearly I feel my own limitations, especially when exercising gifts like writing.

Perhaps gifts are given for just such a reason - to enlighten us to our own weakness, insufficiency, and limits. Useful and beautiful though they may be, there always seems to be an air of finity.

But I'm rambling! Excellent post...I always enjoy hearing about free will as well as creativity.

Robin said...

You never ramble. I like it.